Alex Melen
Insights · Explainer

What to Do When AI Gets Your Business Wrong

Confirm the error repeats by asking the same question several times on more than one AI tool. If it does, follow the sources the AI cites: the wrong fact almost always lives on a real page, such as an outdated directory listing or a stale page on your own site. Fix that page, then allow a few weeks for the AI tools to read it again.

By Alex Melen, co-founder of SmartSites · Nov 17, 2026 · 700 words

Sooner or later a customer says, “ChatGPT told me you don’t offer that.” Or a customer never shows up, because an AI answer listed your Saturday hours wrong or summed up your business from three old reviews. There is no support line to call. You still have more control than it feels like, because of how these tools produce an answer.

Why AI gets a business wrong

Ask ChatGPT or Gemini something timeless and it answers from its training. Ask about anything current or local, such as hours, prices, what a business carries or who is good nearby, and it runs searches behind the scenes, reads the results and writes an answer from what it found.

That means the AI’s picture of your business is a mirror of what is published about you. When it is wrong, it is usually repeating a page that is wrong. That is good news, because a page is something you can fix.

Step 1: Confirm it is a pattern

AI answers change from one run to the next. In Rand Fishkin’s January 2026 SparkToro research, the same prompt returned the same list of businesses less than one time in a hundred. A single odd answer may never come back.

Before you react, ask the same question several times, in a few different phrasings, on more than one tool: ChatGPT, Gemini and Google’s AI Mode. If the wrong claim keeps appearing, you have a real problem. If it appeared once, let it go.

Step 2: Find the page it came from

Google’s AI Overviews and Perplexity almost always show their sources, and ChatGPT shows them when it searches the web. Open every one. The wrong fact is usually sitting on one of these:

  • an outdated directory listing with your old hours, address or phone number
  • a stale page on your own website, such as a service or product you stopped offering
  • a third-party listing or marketplace still showing inventory you sold months ago
  • an old news article or press release

If the answer shows no sources, search the wrong claim in quotes on Google and Bing. The page that states it is usually on the first screen.

Step 3: Fix the source, then wait

Correct your Google Business Profile first, then your own website, then the directory or listing. Remove or redirect pages that are no longer true instead of leaving them up. Then give it time. The AI tools re-read the web continuously, but in my experience the answer changes in weeks, not hours.

Keep a note of what you fixed and when, and run your questions again a month later.

Use your ChatGPT profile for the basics

Since November 10, 2026 there is one more place to correct the record. A business can claim its listing in ChatGPT’s Business Hub and edit its description, category and website. OpenAI says ChatGPT may still use other sources, so this does not replace fixing the page the error came from. It is worth doing for the facts you control. The steps are in how to claim your business in ChatGPT.

Reviews, Reddit and forums

Google’s AI reads forums and Reddit threads and will summarize them for the next person who asks about you. You cannot edit those threads, and you should never post fake ones. Communities catch that quickly and it makes the summary worse.

Search your business name on Reddit once a quarter. If the same complaint keeps coming up, treat it as an operations problem. If people say your fees are a surprise at checkout, change how you present the fees, then let honest reviews catch up. AI summaries follow the reviews; they do not lead them.

A monthly routine

Once a month, ask the AI tools the questions your customers ask: your hours, whether you offer a specific service, who the best provider is in your city. Ask each one a few times. Write down how often you appear, what is said about you and which sources are cited.

When something is wrong three times running, follow the sources and fix the page. That half hour tells you more than most dashboards. The fuller method is in how to measure AI search visibility.

Questions people ask

Can I ask OpenAI or Google to correct an AI answer about my business?

There is no process for correcting an individual answer. AI tools build answers about current and local topics from pages they find on the web, so the practical fix is to correct the page the wrong fact came from. Since November 2026 a business can also claim its ChatGPT listing in Business Hub and edit its basic details.

How long does it take for a corrected fact to show up in AI answers?

Usually weeks, not hours. The AI tools re-read the web continuously but not instantly, and different tools refresh at different speeds. Run the same questions again about a month after the fix.

Does one wrong AI answer matter?

Not on its own. Independent research has found less than a one-in-a-hundred chance of the same prompt returning the same list of businesses twice. Ask the question several times on more than one tool. Only act when the wrong claim repeats.

Where do wrong AI answers about a business usually come from?

Most often from a real page that is out of date: an old directory listing, a stale page on the business’s own website, a third-party listing showing sold inventory, or an old article. Follow the sources the AI cites to find it.

Want this delivered to your team in person?

Alex presents the AI search material as a keynote, breakout or executive briefing, built around your market and your data.