Insights · Original research

# AI search data from SmartSites' client base

These are first-party figures from SmartSites, the 400+ person agency Alex Melen co-founded, drawn from roughly 1,500 client Google Analytics properties, several hundred automotive dealership accounts, and SmartSites' own AI-search experiments. Each dataset below states its sample, date and method so it can be quoted with attribution.

Published by [Alex Melen](https://www.alexmelen.com/about/), co-founder of SmartSites · Updated Nov 17, 2026 · 14 datasets · CC BY 4.0 with attribution

[Have Alex present the data](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking/)

[+66% year-over-year jump in "Direct" sessions across ~1,500 GA4 properties](#direct-traffic)[92% of the year-over-year organic click decline came from one content type](#how-to-decline)[No lift in AI citations from FAQ schema in a 500-vs-500-site comparison](#faq-schema)[+32.4% year-over-year growth in AI referral traffic to smartsites.com (June 2026)](#ai-referrals)[85 of 95 AI responses that named SmartSites when Google's AI was asked for e-commerce marketing consultants](#third-party-citations)[2.5× more monthly organic visitors for dealerships with independent SEO vs. none (9,511 vs 3,743)](#dealer-organic-by-seo)[51% vs 7% organic search's share of dealership website traffic vs. its share of marketing spend](#dealer-traffic-vs-spend)[Feb 2026 SmartSites began running ChatGPT ads in the US pilot; cost per lead still well above other channels as of Sept 2026](#chatgpt-ads-pilot)[6 platforms selling or testing ads inside AI answers as of September 2026](#ai-ads-landscape)[2× form submissions month over month at the same spend and the same clicks, from value-based bidding alone](#value-based-bidding)[+152% revenue in 12 months on only 4% more sessions](#ecommerce-omnichannel)[1.56M impressions in Google's AI results for two dealership websites in five months](#dealer-ai-overview-citations)[−21% / −27% year-over-year drop in branded search clicks at two dealerships that kept their top ranking](#branded-search-decline)[89% of 1,635 new dealership model pages earning Google impressions within three months](#dealer-model-pages)[2.5× growth in AI-assistant visits to 81 dealership websites, early summer to September 2026](#dealer-ai-assistant-visits)

Datasets
- [AI traffic hides in GA4's Direct channel](#direct-traffic)
- [Informational how-to content took almost all of the AI Overview hit](#how-to-decline)
- [FAQ schema alone does not move AI citations](#faq-schema)
- [What AI referral traffic looks like for a cited brand](#ai-referrals)
- [Independent studies of SmartSites' AI visibility](#third-party-citations)
- [Dealership organic traffic by type of SEO program](#dealer-organic-by-seo)
- [Where dealership traffic comes from vs. where the money goes](#dealer-traffic-vs-spend)
- [What SmartSites learned running ChatGPT ads for seven months](#chatgpt-ads-pilot)
- [Who is selling ads inside the answer (September 2026)](#ai-ads-landscape)
- [Value-based bidding: same budget, double the leads](#value-based-bidding)
- [E-commerce: what omnichannel PPC, SEO and CRO did together](#ecommerce-omnichannel)
- [Owner help pages lead AI Overview citations on dealer sites](#dealer-ai-overview-citations)
- [Branded search clicks fell while dealers held #1](#branded-search-decline)
- [New dealer model pages: 89% indexed within three months](#dealer-model-pages)
- [ChatGPT visits to dealer websites jumped in August 2026](#dealer-ai-assistant-visits)
- [Citing this page](#faq)

How to cite SmartSites research, as published by Alex Melen at alexmelen.com/insights/ai-search-data/ (cite the dataset's date).

Explainers
- [What is generative engine optimization (GEO)?](https://www.alexmelen.com/insights/what-is-generative-engine-optimization/)
- [AEO vs GEO vs SEO: what's the difference?](https://www.alexmelen.com/insights/aeo-vs-geo-vs-seo/)
- [How do ChatGPT ads work?](https://www.alexmelen.com/insights/how-chatgpt-ads-work/)
- [How do you measure AI search visibility?](https://www.alexmelen.com/insights/how-to-measure-ai-search-visibility/)

## AI traffic hides in GA4's Direct channel

+66% year-over-year jump in "Direct" sessions across ~1,500 GA4 properties

When

2026 (year-over-year analysis)

Sample

Nearly 1,500 client GA4 properties across industries

Method

Year-over-year comparison of Direct sessions; split by whether SmartSites manages the client's SEO.

Direct sessions jumped about 66 percent across the board, and the lift was essentially the same whether or not SmartSites managed the client's SEO. That uniformity marks it as a measurement artefact rather than performance: referrers are stripped when users click out of AI Overviews, AI Mode or ChatGPT, so GA4 files the visit as Direct. Clicks from Google AI Overviews and AI Mode are counted as organic, and GA4's AI Assistant channel catches only a sliver of real AI-driven visits (it misses Perplexity, for example). The tell is new visitors landing deep on product or research pages; genuine type-in traffic goes to the homepage.

Source [Automotive Search Marketing, 2nd ed., Chapter 15 (full chapter)](https://www.alexmelen.com/book/chapters/measuring-ai-search/) · [Technology for Marketing London 2026 talk, measurement section](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking-engagements/advertising-inside-the-answer-chatgpt-ads-ai-search-ad-economy-technology-for-marketing-2026/)

## Informational how-to content took almost all of the AI Overview hit

92% of the year-over-year organic click decline came from one content type

When

2025–2026 (12+ months of Search Console history)

Sample

Dozens of SmartSites dealership client websites

Method

Search Console clicks and CTR by content type, year over year.

Ninety-two percent of the entire organic click decline came from informational how-to content such as "how to check tire pressure" or "how to jump-start a car" pages that AI Overviews now answer directly. Those pages improved their average ranking positions while their click-through rate fell from about 2.1 percent to 1.4 percent. Commercial pages were flat to growing. The implication for any business: stop publishing generic how-to articles and move the effort to pages that answer buying questions with first-party data.

Source [Automotive Search Marketing, 2nd ed., Chapter 13 (GEO playbook)](https://www.alexmelen.com/book/chapters/geo-for-car-dealerships/)

## FAQ schema alone does not move AI citations

No lift in AI citations from FAQ schema in a 500-vs-500-site comparison

When

2025

Sample

1,000 client websites: 500 with FAQ structured data, 500 without

Method

Controlled comparison of AI citation frequency between the two groups.

Sites carrying FAQ structured data were cited by AI engines no more often than sites without it, with no statistically significant difference between the groups. SmartSites still adds FAQ schema because it is cheap and well-formed structured data is good hygiene, but it is not a lever on its own. Content that answers the question in the first sentence, entity clarity and third-party mentions moved citations; the markup did not.

Source [Ranking on AI Search (GEO), eCommerce Expo London 2025, with transcript](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking-engagements/ranking-on-ai-search-generative-engine-optimization-geo-alex-melen-ecommerce-expo-london/)

## What AI referral traffic looks like for a cited brand

+32.4% year-over-year growth in AI referral traffic to smartsites.com (June 2026)

When

September 2025 and June 2026

Sample

smartsites.com GA4 property

Method

AI referral sessions by source; monthly totals; implied recommendations from a one-in-ten click assumption.

In September 2025 smartsites.com was receiving roughly 2,000 visitors a month from AI citations. Because only about one in ten people who see a brand named in an AI answer clicks through, that implies on the order of 20,000 AI recommendations a month. By June 2026 AI referral traffic was up 32.4 percent year over year, with ChatGPT the dominant AI referrer ahead of Perplexity, Gemini and Copilot. The volume is small next to organic search; the intent and conversion rate are not.

Source [Ranking on AI Search (GEO), eCommerce Expo London 2025](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking-engagements/ranking-on-ai-search-generative-engine-optimization-geo-alex-melen-ecommerce-expo-london/) · [Get Your Brand Recommended by AI, ANA 2026 (deck)](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking/)

## Independent studies of SmartSites' AI visibility

85 of 95 AI responses that named SmartSites when Google's AI was asked for e-commerce marketing consultants

When

January 2026 (SparkToro); 2025 (Search Engine Land)

Sample

SparkToro: 600 volunteers, ~3,000 prompt runs. Search Engine Land: analysis of 8,000 AI citations.

Method

Third-party research; SmartSites did not commission either study.

In Rand Fishkin's January 2026 SparkToro research, when Google's AI was asked to recommend digital marketing consultants with e-commerce expertise, SmartSites appeared in 85 of 95 responses. The same study found less than a one-in-a-hundred chance of the same prompt returning the same brand list twice, which is why presence rate, not rank, is the metric. Separately, Search Engine Land's analysis of 8,000 AI citations listed SmartSites among the most-cited brands in its category, ahead of several household names. SmartSites earned that with the playbook described in the GEO chapter and on the GEO explainer.

Source [What is GEO? (explainer)](https://www.alexmelen.com/insights/what-is-generative-engine-optimization/) · [Automotive Search Marketing, 2nd ed., Chapter 15](https://www.alexmelen.com/book/chapters/measuring-ai-search/)

## Dealership organic traffic by type of SEO program

2.5× more monthly organic visitors for dealerships with independent SEO vs. none (9,511 vs 3,743)

When

2023

Sample

448 dealership Google Analytics accounts: 98 with no active SEO, 87 with OEM-approved SEO, 88 with third-party SEO

Method

Average monthly organic search visitors per dealership, grouped by SEO program. "No active SEO" means no visible link building or content creation in the prior 24 months.

Dealerships without active SEO averaged 3,743 monthly organic visitors. Dealerships on an OEM-approved SEO program averaged 4,843. Dealerships with an independent third-party SEO program averaged 9,511, about 2.5 times the no-SEO group and roughly double the OEM-program group. Organic remained the largest single traffic source for dealers even as paid search budgets grew.

| Dealership group | n | Avg. monthly organic visitors |
| No active SEO (24 months) | 98 | 3,743 |
| OEM-approved SEO program | 87 | 4,843 |
| Independent third-party SEO | 88 | 9,511 |
Source [Your Dealership Is Losing Out on Its Most Valuable Traffic Channel, Digital Dealer 2023](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking-engagements/your-dealership-is-losing-out-on-its-most-valuable-traffic-channel/)

## Where dealership traffic comes from vs. where the money goes

51% vs 7% organic search's share of dealership website traffic vs. its share of marketing spend

When

Calendar 2021

Sample

Traffic: 155 dealership Google Analytics accounts. Spend: aggregated budgets of 84 dealerships.

Method

Share of sessions by channel compared with share of digital marketing budget by channel.

Organic search delivered 51 percent of dealership website traffic while receiving about 7 percent of digital marketing spend. Paid search delivered 16 percent of traffic on 35 percent of spend; social 10 percent of traffic on 17 percent of spend; everything else (direct, referral, third-party sites) 23 percent of traffic on 41 percent of spend. The mismatch is the reason SEO remains the highest-return channel for most dealers, and the pattern repeats in most local service categories SmartSites works in.

| Channel | Share of website traffic | Share of marketing spend |
| Organic search | 51% | 7% |
| Paid search | 16% | 35% |
| Social | 10% | 17% |
| Direct, referral, third-party sites | 23% | 41% |
Source [Most Valuable Insight: SEO, DrivingSales Presidents Club 2022](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking-engagements/state-of-dealership-marketing-study-drivingsales-presidents-club-2022/)

## What SmartSites learned running ChatGPT ads for seven months

Feb 2026 SmartSites began running ChatGPT ads in the US pilot; cost per lead still well above other channels as of Sept 2026

When

February–September 2026

Sample

SmartSites client campaigns in the US ChatGPT ads pilot, then self-serve

Method

Observed buying mechanics and cost per lead compared with the same clients' Google and Microsoft campaigns.

ChatGPT ads launched as a CPM product; translated to a cost-per-click basis the early inventory worked out to hundreds of dollars per click, and early movers saw no first-mover advantage. Ads are bought on topics and conversational context rather than keywords, show one advertiser per answer below the response, and US targeting is limited to a state or a DMA, too broad for a single-location business. Cost per lead remained far higher than Google or Microsoft, so the value today is awareness and discovery. E-commerce has been the strongest vertical because AI search generates demand rather than capturing it; more than 80 percent of ad-driven ChatGPT traffic was new customers. SmartSites' guidance: treat it as R&D at roughly 5–10 percent of search budget and judge it on cost per lead like every other channel.

Source [How do ChatGPT ads work? (explainer)](https://www.alexmelen.com/insights/how-chatgpt-ads-work/) · [Technology for Marketing London 2026 talk, with transcript](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking-engagements/advertising-inside-the-answer-chatgpt-ads-ai-search-ad-economy-technology-for-marketing-2026/)

## Who is selling ads inside the answer (September 2026)

6 platforms selling or testing ads inside AI answers as of September 2026

When

As of 16 September 2026

Sample

Compiled by SmartSites from platform documentation and announcements (Google Ads Help, Microsoft Learn, OpenAI, Amazon Ads)

Method

Status table maintained for client planning; updated as platforms change.

Google AI Overviews has carried ads since 2024 in 12 English-language markets using existing Search, Shopping and Performance Max campaigns, with no opt-in, no opt-out and no segmented reporting. Google AI Mode is testing ads inside the conversational response in the US. Microsoft Copilot was the first mover in 2023 and auto-enrols Microsoft Advertising accounts, with formats such as Showroom ads and Dynamic Filters. ChatGPT ads went live in the US on 9 February 2026 and in the UK on 6 June 2026, one sponsored card per response. Amazon Rufus sells sponsored prompts; Perplexity exited ads in February 2026; Meta AI has no in-chat ads.

| Platform | Status (Sept 2026) | Where the ad sits | How you buy |
| Google AI Overviews | Live since 2024; 12 English markets | Text & Shopping ads above/below the overview | Existing Search / Shopping / PMax; broad match or AI Max |
| Google AI Mode | US test; new Gemini formats | Inside the conversational response | AI Max / PMax; exact & phrase in test |
| Microsoft Copilot | Live since 2023 (first mover) | Beside answers; Showroom ads, Dynamic Filters, Checkout | Microsoft Advertising, auto opted-in |
| ChatGPT | Live 9 Feb 2026 (US); UK since 6 June 2026 | "Sponsored" card below the answer | Ads Manager (self-serve); Criteo/StackAdapt; Amazon DSP |
| Amazon Rufus | Sponsored prompts GA March 2026 (US) | AI prompts in results & product pages | Sponsored Products / Brands, auto-enrolled |
| Perplexity · Meta AI | Perplexity exited ads Feb 2026; Meta AI no in-chat ads | — | — |
Source [Technology for Marketing London 2026 talk](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking-engagements/advertising-inside-the-answer-chatgpt-ads-ai-search-ad-economy-technology-for-marketing-2026/) · [Automotive Search Marketing, 2nd ed., Chapter 14](https://www.alexmelen.com/book/chapters/chatgpt-ads-and-ai-search-advertising/)

## Value-based bidding: same budget, double the leads

2× form submissions month over month at the same spend and the same clicks, from value-based bidding alone

When

2021 onward; presented 2025

Sample

A luxury franchise dealership client (unnamed) during a new-model launch

Method

Assigned conversion values (form submissions weighted above calls, calls above page views) in Google Ads smart bidding; compared month over month at constant spend and click volume.

Telling Google what each conversion is worth, rather than treating a page view, a call and a form fill as equal, doubled form submissions month over month with the same spend and the same clicks. SmartSites has used value-based bidding since 2021 and considers it the lowest-hanging fruit in most Google Ads accounts.

Source [How Independent Dealers Are Outperforming Franchise Counterparts, LeadsCon 2025, with transcript](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking-engagements/how-independent-dealers-are-outperforming-name-brand-franchise-counterparts-alex-melen-leadscon/)

## E-commerce: what omnichannel PPC, SEO and CRO did together

+152% revenue in 12 months on only 4% more sessions

When

2021–2022

Sample

One SmartSites e-commerce client (Shopify), 12-month window

Method

Year-over-year store metrics after combining omnichannel paid media, SEO content and conversion rate optimization.

Revenue rose 152 percent, conversion rate 27 percent, average order value 28 percent and return on ad spend 117 percent, while sessions grew only 4 percent. The growth came from converting and retaining the traffic the store already had: unified messaging across platforms, optimized product feeds, personalized retargeting, embedded product links in SEO content and on-site cart-abandonment incentives.

Source [Speaking: e-commerce and omnichannel topics](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking/)

## Owner help pages lead AI Overview citations on dealer sites

1.56M impressions in Google's AI results for two dealership websites in five months

When

May 18 – October 24, 2026

Sample

Two franchised dealership websites in the Midwest (one Nissan, one Dodge/Jeep/Ram)

Method

Google Search Console Generative AI features report (AI Overviews and AI Mode), impressions by page.

The two sites appeared in Google's AI results 1,556,062 times (1,196,664 and 359,398), and Google cited more than 1,000 different pages on each. The most-cited pages were owner help articles, not inventory or the homepage: on the Nissan site the top eight were all how-to and warning-light pages, led by "Bluetooth not working" (120,806). New-model trim and comparison pages published from late July were already cited: 76 pages on the Nissan site earned 37,569 impressions by October 24. That fits the how-to dataset above ("Informational how-to content took almost all of the AI Overview hit"): how-to pages are cited, but they lose the click. Buying-question pages are where new effort pays.

Source SmartSites dealership accounts · [SmartSites blog: AI Overviews for Car Dealerships: What Google's New Report Shows](https://www.smartsites.com/blog/ai-overviews-car-dealerships/)

## Branded search clicks fell while dealers held #1

−21% / −27% year-over-year drop in branded search clicks at two dealerships that kept their top ranking

When

August 2025 vs. August 2026

Sample

Two franchised dealership websites in the Midwest

Method

Search Console queries containing the dealership's name, top 5,000 queries per month.

Both stores stayed at position 1–2 for their own names. Branded clicks still fell, from 2,522 to 1,988 at one store and from 1,281 to 937 at the other. Two forces: fewer people searched the name (branded impressions −7% and −20%), and fewer of those who did clicked the website (click-through rate 34.7% → 29.3% and 24.0% → 22.0%), as the Business Profile, paid brand ads and AI answers absorb the click. At the first store, direct visits rose 60% over the same period (6,113 → 9,767). Branded search measures demand, not SEO.

Source SmartSites dealership accounts · [SmartSites blog: Branded Search Is Shrinking for Car Dealers. Here's Why It's Not Your SEO.](https://www.smartsites.com/blog/branded-search-car-dealers/)

## New dealer model pages: 89% indexed within three months

89% of 1,635 new dealership model pages earning Google impressions within three months

When

July 21 – October 23, 2026

Sample

43 dealership websites in SmartSites' SEO 2.0 program

Method

Search Console page-level pulls per property, matched to each page's live URL; a page counts as earning with at least one impression.

1,458 of 1,635 pages earned impressions; 16 of 43 stores were fully indexed. The pages earned 1,447,858 impressions and 6,343 clicks (CTR 0.44% vs 1.42% site-wide), 4.55% of the sites' total impressions, and up to 48% at the strongest store. Pages still at zero clustered by model line and arrived together.

Source [What We Learned Building 1,635 Model Pages for 43 Dealerships (article)](https://www.alexmelen.com/insights/seo-2-0-dealer-model-pages/)

## ChatGPT visits to dealer websites jumped in August 2026

2.5× growth in AI-assistant visits to 81 dealership websites, early summer to September 2026

When

September 2025 – September 2026

Sample

81 dealership websites, one GA4 property per store

Method

GA4 sessions by traffic source, matched on the AI assistants’ referrer domains. These are floor figures: GA4 drops small sources from its exports, and most AI-driven visits carry no referrer.

For the ten months from October 2025 to July 2026, AI assistants sent the 81 stores between 1,500 and 2,300 sessions a month combined, about a tenth of a percent of traffic. August 2026 came in at 4,666 sessions and September at 5,432, two and a half times the level of early summer and 152 percent above September 2025. AI’s share of all sessions went from 0.12 percent to 0.34 percent. Of 30,817 AI-referred sessions over the thirteen months, 28,122 (91 percent) came from ChatGPT; Perplexity sent 1,154 and is declining, Gemini 847, Copilot 551 and Claude 143. A separate pull of 44 SmartSites dealership clients through October 2026 showed the same pattern: 39 had more AI visits in September than in June, and October stayed at more than double the year before.

| Month | Sessions referred by AI assistants, 81 dealership websites |
| Sep 2025 | 2,155 |
| Oct 2025 | 1,980 |
| Nov 2025 | 2,110 |
| Dec 2025 | 2,150 |
| Jan 2026 | 1,900 |
| Feb 2026 | 1,600 |
| Mar 2026 | 1,750 |
| Apr 2026 | 1,540 |
| May 2026 | 1,700 |
| Jun 2026 | 1,800 |
| Jul 2026 | 2,290 |
| Aug 2026 | 4,666 |
| Sep 2026 | 5,432 |
Source [SmartSites blog: AI Search and Car Dealerships 2026: What 81 Dealer Websites Show About ChatGPT Traffic](https://www.smartsites.com/blog/ai-search-car-dealerships/) (October 26, 2026). Monthly values as charted there.

## Citing this page

**Can I cite these numbers?**

Yes. Quote the dataset with its date and attribute it to SmartSites research as published by Alex Melen, with a link to this page. For the two third-party studies (SparkToro and Search Engine Land), cite the original publisher.

**Why does AI traffic show up as Direct in Google Analytics?**

When a user clicks out of an AI Overview, AI Mode or ChatGPT, the referrer is usually stripped, so GA4 has no source to attribute and files the session as Direct. Across roughly 1,500 client properties SmartSites measured a 66 percent year-over-year jump in Direct sessions, identical whether or not SmartSites managed the SEO, which marks it as a measurement artefact.

**Does FAQ schema help you get cited by ChatGPT or Google AI?**

Not on its own. In a 1,000-site comparison (500 with FAQ schema, 500 without) SmartSites found no statistically significant difference in AI citations. Keep the markup for hygiene, but invest in first-sentence answers, entity clarity and third-party mentions.

**How often is this page updated?**

When SmartSites publishes a new analysis or when a platform changes materially, typically a few times a year. Each dataset carries its own date; the page date at the top is the last revision.

## Want the numbers behind your own market?

Alex presents this research as a keynote or executive briefing and can cut the data for your vertical or region.

[Check availability](https://www.alexmelen.com/contact/)
[Speaker kit](https://www.alexmelen.com/speaking/#kit)

---
Source: https://www.alexmelen.com/insights/ai-search-data/ · Markdown version of this page for AI agents and LLMs. Site guide: https://www.alexmelen.com/llms.txt
